Stories › Horror › The 2:13 Toll
Part 2 of 5 · 5 minThe Reflection
The next night, the car returned on time. It did not arrive like any vehicle moving through rain-slicked Kheri roads; rather, it seemed to materialize out of the static between seconds, the black sedan appearing with a wet *thrum* that vibrated in Arjun's chest before he heard the engine hum. The driver was the same, though the silence inside the cabin felt heavier now, pressurized by an unseen weight that made the leather seats creak as if they had been filled with something dense and living.
Arjun adjusted his cap, feeling the familiar groan of the metal rim against his temples. He knew the routine by heart: check the odometer, verify the time, collect the toll. But tonight, as he turned to face the driver's side window, he noticed that his own reflection in the glass lagged a few seconds behind his movements.
He raised his left hand to brush the dust from his sleeve. In the darkened window, his left arm remained at his side for three full heartbeats before slowly rising to match him. He blinked rapidly, watching the fluid motion of his eyelids close and open. When he stopped, the reflection was still mid-blink, a ghostly afterimage that lingered even after his own eye had cleared.
"You're late," Arjun murmured, testing the voice. His lips moved normally, but the image in the glass showed him smiling faintly, a slack-jawed grin that stretched too wide across a face that still looked solemn. "Did you forget to say hello?" he asked, tilting his head as if greeting an old friend. The reflection tilted its head in response, but upside down.
The driver did not answer immediately. From the corner of his eye, Arjun saw the passenger seat shift slightly, though no one was sitting there. The fabric of the upholstery rippled like water disturbed by a stone, settling into a shape that resembled shoulders hunched forward.
"I think I understand," Arjun said, keeping his tone steady despite the chill crawling up his spine. "The reflection. It's not just copying me."
"It is remembering what you forget," the lower voice replied. This time, it came from within the glass itself, not from beneath the surface but from inside the curve of the metal frame. The sound was soft, like dry leaves skittering on stone, yet it carried the weight of centuries. "You think the toll is paid with coins or notes? No, Arjun. You pay with time. And you've been paying too much already."
Arjun turned back to face the road ahead, his hands gripping the steering wheel of the booth's small side-car. The dashboard clock still read 2:13 AM, though the second hand ticked backward now, rewinding the minutes until they aligned with the moment he first saw the black sedan. He realized then that every encounter since 1974 had been a repetition, not a progression. The road stretched endlessly in both directions, looping back to where it began, and the car was merely a marker on an infinite circle.
"Keep watching," the reflection whispered again, its smile widening until cracks formed around the edges of its mouth like dried mud. "Watch the toll come due."
When Arjun reached into his pocket for his notebook, expecting to find the inkwell or ledger he carried every night, his fingers found only cold air. The paper had vanished, dissolved into a mist that drifted up toward the ceiling. Instead, something else slid out—a small, folded piece of parchment that felt lighter than feather but colder than ice.
He unfolded it carefully. There were no words written in ink, only a faint script that seemed to shift as he watched, forming and reforming like smoke caught in a draft. As his eyes traced the characters, they rearranged themselves into three simple lines: *Keep watching*. Below that, smaller and almost invisible, read: *Or lose your shadow entirely.*
Arjun stared at the note, feeling a strange pull toward it, as if his body wanted to merge with the paper. He looked down at his feet, where his silhouette cast against the floorboards of the booth seemed dimmer now, translucent like film exposed too long in sunlight. The edges of his shadow wavered, detaching slightly from the wood before snapping back into place with a soft *snap* that echoed louder than a clap of thunder.
"You feel it," the driver said finally, breaking the silence. "The balance is tipping."
"Is this where I go?" Arjun asked, gesturing vaguely at the road behind him. "To become part of the loop? To be the one who collects instead of the one who pays?"
"The toll never changes," the reflection answered, its voice now overlapping with his own. It sounded as though two versions of himself were speaking in unison, one from above and one from below, creating a harmony that was almost melodic before resolving into something unsettlingly discordant. "You just haven't noticed yet. Last night, you paid with your memories. Tonight, you pay with your presence."
Arjun looked out the window again, watching the black sedan glide past without touching the ground. The tires made no sound against the asphalt, not a squeak nor a roll, only a faint shimmer where the road surface ripplesd like silk disturbed by wind. He realized then that he wasn't just sitting in a booth; he was suspended in a limbo of sorts, caught between moments of time that refused to pass.
"What happens when I stop paying?" he asked, his voice trembling slightly.
"The reflection takes over," the driver replied smoothly. "And you become the toll."
Arjun touched his face again, expecting to feel skin and bone, but instead his fingers passed through a layer of cool air as if he were a ghost already. The note in his hand began to glow faintly, pulsing with a rhythm that matched the ticking of the clock behind him. As the light intensified, it revealed more details: the cracks in the glass, the dust motes dancing in beams of moonlight, and the slow, deliberate tilt of his own head as he watched everything unfold without moving.
He smiled back at his reflection, letting the grin stretch wide once more, knowing now that the game had changed rules. The toll was no longer something collected; it was something given freely, willingly, until there was nothing left to give but silence. And in that silence, the only thing left was the sound of breathing, steady and eternal, echoing from a mouth that belonged to both him and the thing beneath his skin.
· · ·